Carroll Heights Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale in Tampa, FL

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Carroll Heights SubDv. ⋅ 33612 Zip Code

This rare 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1,880 sq. ft. of total living space, including a detached above-garage apartment/mother-in-law suite (approx. 450 sq. ft.) with its own full bath, already plumbed and ready for a kitchen, making it ideal for rental income, extended family, guests, or a private home office. Situated on a sprawling 0.51-acre double lot that backs to a cul-de-sac with a second gated entrance, the property also presents subdivision potential with space to build an additional home and private driveway, adding tremendous long-term value. The main residence features solid bones and excellent potential, including a metal roof, welcoming front and back porches, and a deep 2-car carport. A detached 2-car garage/workshop enhances the property’s functionality. Inside, the expansive family room with a brick wood-burning fireplace flows effortlessly to the large backyard, connecting seamlessly to the garage and apartment—perfect for entertaining or family living. This property is ideal for investors, rehabbers, and cash buyers, but also perfect for end-user buyers looking for a spacious home with flexibility. Update the main house to your style, enjoy the detached apartment ready for a kitchen, or explore the lot’s potential to subdivide and build another home. Location is prime: nestled in Forrest Hills near Babe Zaharias Golf Course, within walking distance to Lake Magdalene Elementary School, and just minutes from Roy Haynes Park and Recreation Center. With income potential, expansion possibilities, and flexible living options, this property is a rare opportunity for both investors and homeowners looking to maximize value and lifestyle.

1715 W Overpar Drive, Tampa

$400,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Carroll Heights SubDv. ⋅ 33612 Zip Code

Welcome to your new home in Forest Hills! This 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home offers 1,262 sq. ft. of living space on an amazing ½-acre lot shaded by beautiful, mature oak trees. A true diamond in the rough, this property is full of potential and ready for you to transform into your dream home! Inside, you’re greeted by a sun-filled living room with gleaming laminate floors that flow seamlessly into the dining area — an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. French doors open to the patio, creating a natural transition to outdoor living, ideal for hosting, gardening, or simply enjoying the serene, park-like setting. The kitchen includes a convenient bar for extra seating, while a perfectly placed window frames views of the amazing backyard. Just off the kitchen, a large laundry room provides plenty of storage and added functionality. The primary bedroom features a private bathroom and spacious closets. Warm hardwood floors make it a cozy retreat where you can relax after a long day. Each of the additional bedrooms also offers hardwood floors and generous closets, creating flexible spaces for family, guests, or a home office. The bathrooms still have the vintage tile work that allow you to integrate the original character with your own modernized features. The expansive backyard is more than large enough to add a separate mother in law suite or casita! The location is hard to beat — just a short walk to Babe Zaharias Golf Course with its Pro Shop, Clubhouse Restaurant, and community events. You’re also minutes from Busch Gardens, Lettuce Lake Park, ZooTampa, USF, and just a quick drive to Downtown Tampa. Don’t miss this opportunity to make a Forest Hills gem your own. Schedule your private showing today!

1719 W Overpar Drive Drive, Tampa

$462,750

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Carroll Heights SubDv. ⋅ 33612 Zip Code

Welcome to your 3 bedroom 2 bath dream home located in the highly desirable, family-friendly neighborhood of historic Forest Hills. This bright and inviting home offers 1,415 square feet of open concept living space, boasting quality and custom craftsmanship touches throughout all its updated features. Constructed of solid concrete block, this home features a fully fenced backyard with gates on both sides, a matching storage shed for all your lawn care tools, as well as an expansive concrete patio oasis, perfect for entertaining. Stepping through the double doors at the entrance, you're greeted by a cozy foyer welcoming you in with tile lined pathways to all areas of the house. The spacious 2 car garage provides direct access into the dining area and kitchen for convenience in bringing your groceries in. The stylishly remodeled kitchen sparkles with custom solid wood shaker cabinets, soft closing drawers, stainless steel appliances, and exquisite granite counters highlighting the extensive 11-ft countertop connecting the kitchen and living room. At the center of the home, the open living room features a wood burning fireplace framed by a custom crafted mantel and impressive 20-ft vaulted ceilings accented with tailored skylights. Stunning hurricane impact sliders and windows brighten every space with natural sunlight. The serene master bedroom features added bonuses of an ensuite bathroom showcasing the double vanity, granite countertop and travertine tiled walk-in shower as well as two closets (one being a walk-in). Two generously sized carpeted bedrooms share the guest bathroom, which has been beautifully updated with solid wood cabinets, double vanity, travertine tile and has separation from the toilet and relaxing soaking tub. The home has a brand-new roof with a 25-year warranty (April 2025) and a new HVAC system (July 2023). Experience carefree living with no HOA, no CDD, no flood insurance and no direct neighbors behind the house. Prepare to fall in love with this centrally located home within walking distance to the nearest elementary school, additionally providing convenient access to USF, downtown, the airport, major freeways, top schools, medical facilities, world-renowned beaches and an array of shops and restaurants. Hurry on this ideal opportunity.

11315 N Armenia Avenue, Tampa

Browse All Carroll Heights Properties for Sale

Carroll Heights Real Estate & Homes